Put brown sugar into a warmed, heat-proof mug with peel studded with cloves and cinnamon stick. Pour in a little boiling water and stir until sugar is dissolved. Add rum, creme de Cacao, and fill with boiling water. Stir and top with butter and grated nutmeg.
Buy the equipment
Here are our top picks from Amazon of cocktail making equipment to make a St. vincent hot buttered rum.